AI Makes Bad Managers

It’s performance-review season and I’m watching managers kneecap their careers. Gleefully they share the best prompts to have ChatGPT write their performance assessments - exactly the sort of shortcut that guarantees they’ll never get better at the job. Below, we’ll break down why AI’s leaky interface is a crutch, not an abstraction layer, and how leaning on it is already stunting growth. Performance Assessments Performance write-ups feel brutal because you’re not great at management. Great managers improvise on feedback the way a jazz soloist riffs on a theme - always on, always smooth. That fluency only comes from thousands of hours of uncomfortable reps: hard conversations, careful wordsmithing, and the stress of getting it right. A performance assessment is management boiled down to a page. It demands precision, empathy, and strategic thinking. Offloading that to AI means skipping the workout; your team might hear something that sounds okay, but you’ve gained zero coaching musc ... Read full article.