My wife is the politically active one in our house. She's the person who shows up: rallies, election day volunteering, local organization meetings, city council sessions. She does the work. I'm a software engineer (she is too, but she's more politically active). I build things for other people during the day, and until recently, that was the extent of my contribution to the world.
Then we moved to El Paso, and everything changed.
The talk of the town in local political circles was a set of data centers being proposed in nearby communities. Big facilities, major implications for water usage, land, and the community's future. My wife dove in. She connected with organizers, attended meetings, tried to get the full picture.
But by the time people got organized enough to start showing up to city council meetings, the papers were already signed. The decision had been made. The window for public input had opened and closed while the community was still figuring out what was happening.
That moment stuck with me. Not because the outcome was unusual (it isn't), but because the reason was so fixable. People cared. They were willing to show up. They just didn't know soon enough.
The Notification Problem
What happened in the El Paso area wasn't a failure of civic will. It was a failure of civic infrastructure.
The organizations trying to mobilize around the data center issue were doing everything they could with the tools they had: group chats, shared Google Docs, someone manually checking the city council agenda every few days. The same improvised setup that grassroots groups everywhere rely on.
The problem is that this setup doesn't scale to the speed of government. A committee hearing gets scheduled. An agenda item gets added. A vote gets moved up. If nobody catches it in time, the window closes. And for community organizations without dedicated staff, "catching it in time" means someone happened to check the right website on the right day.
Meanwhile, the organizations on the other side of these decisions (developers, corporations, industry groups) have professional lobbyists with $30,000-per-year legislative tracking platforms. They know the moment a bill moves. They know exactly which officials to contact and when. They don't miss windows because their tools don't let them.
... continue reading