GoKawiilSomeone proposes an idea in a meeting. It's new, it's different, and it would take effort. Before they've finished explaining it, three people have already thought of reasons it won't work.
"I haven't heard any customers request this." "We can't use Python for that, it's too slow." "That introduces too much complexity." "We tried something like that before and it didn't work." "DevOps won't want to support another service." "People are used to the way it works now."
None of these people are wrong or stupid. And none of them have added any value.
The Uphill Battle
There is a fundamental asymmetry between proposing an idea and shooting one down. Proposing requires imagination, courage, and the ability to see something that doesn't exist yet. Shooting one down requires a single sentence and no imagination at all.
It takes five minutes to explain how an idea could open up a new market segment. It takes two seconds to say "that sounds risky." But in a meeting, the two feel equivalent.
No amount of criticism, objection, or risk identification will ever, by itself, create value. Criticism can prevent mistakes, and that matters. But it is fundamentally about preservation, not creation. The only thing that can create value is an idea. If all you ever do is shoot ideas down, you have never added value. You have only avoided losing it.
It follows a predictable pattern. The first step is to hear an idea you don't fully understand. The second is to find a flaw. The third is to assume the flaw outweighs the potential you never explored. The fourth is to kill the idea. The fifth is to walk out feeling like you contributed something valuable.
The Campfire Critic
The campfire critic isn't trying to put out your fire. They're just standing over you, hands in their pockets, observing that the wood is wet, the wind is picking up, and they once tried to start a fire like this and it didn't work. They're not malicious. They're not even wrong. But while they're talking, the flame you were sheltering just went out.
... continue reading