GoKawiilTerminal User Interfaces (TUIs) are making a comeback. DHH’s Omarchy is made of three types of user interfaces: TUIs, for immediate feedback and bonus geek points, webapps because 37signals (his company) sells SAAS web applications and the unavoidable gnome-style native applications that really do not fit well in the style of the distro.
The same pattern occurred around 10 years ago in code editors. We came from the native editors of BBEdit, Textmate (also promoted by DHH), Notedpad++ and Sublime to Electro-powered apps like Atom, VSCode and all its forks. The hardcore, moved to vim or emacs, trading immediate feedback and higher usability for the steepest learning curve I’ve seen.
Windows
The lesson is clear: Native applications are losing. Windows is doing the GUI library standard joke. Because one API does not have success, they make up another one, just for that one to fail within the sea of alternatives that exist.
MFC (1992) wrapped Win32 in C++. If Win32 was inelegant, MFC was Win32 wearing a tuxedo made of other tuxedos. Then came OLE. COM. ActiveX. None of these were really GUI frameworks – they were component architectures – but they infected every corner of Windows development and introduced a level of cognitive complexity that makes Kierkegaard read like Hemingway.
— Jeffrey Snover, in Microsoft hasn’t had a coherent GUI strategy since Petzold
Since then, Microsoft has gone through Winforms, WPF, Silverlight, WinUIs, MAUI without success. Many enterprise and personal desktop application still rely on Electron Apps, and the last memory of coherent visual integration of the whole OS I have is of Windows 98 or 2000.
It turns out that it’s a lot of work to recreate one’s OS and UI APIs every few years. Coupled with the intermittent attempts at sandboxing and deprecating “too powerful” functionality, the result is that each new layer has gaps, where you can’t do certain things which were possible in the previous framework.
— Domenic Denicola, in Windows Native App Development Is a Mess
Linux
... continue reading