GoKawiilFor the past month the story of a man who discovered almost a million dollars worth of rare trading cards in a Texas dumpster has enthralled a niche subset of the Yu-Gi-Oh trading card game community.
At the end of March, a man began to sell massive amounts of rare Yu-Gi-Oh cards online. He claimed he’d found them in the trash, but people in the community worried he’d stolen them. His posts on Facebook, TikTok, and eBay became erratic. He fought with people in the comments and said he’d made tens of thousands of dollars selling cards. Then his mom showed up on Facebook to defend him.
The seller spoke with 404 Media on condition that we not use his name while he secures legal counsel. He referred to the cards as “thrown away” and said they were found in a dumpster as part of a security breach involving a contractor. He said it “involves 500,000 bulk cards (including high-value Caitlin Clark and [Quarter Century Rare] stock and 400+ factory uncut sheets.” The seller said that he’d “filed formal reports with Konami’s legal department regarding the contractor’s negligence.”He did not respond to follow-up questions.
“The sale of uncut sheets is not allowed,” Konami, the company that owns Yu-Gi-Oh, told me in an email and did not respond to follow-up questions.
404 Media wasn’t able to confirm how the seller obtained them, but the uncut sheets of Yu-Gi-Oh cards, normally tightly controlled and highly valuable collector’s items, are real.
It all started on March 23 with a weird listing on eBay for a rare uncut sheet of a Blue Eyes Silver Dragon Yu-Gi-Oh card . Uncut sheets are a rarity in card collecting. A printer typically prints out a massive sheet of cards and then cuts them to size before packing them to send to distributors. Mistakes happen. Sometimes printers misalign trays , cut the cards wrong, or put text in the wrong place . And sometimes uncut sheets of cards without errors also find their way to the market.
The printer is supposed to destroy these mistakes, but some make it to market. When that happens they become collectors items worth thousands of dollars. Konami, the company behind Yu-Gi-Oh, controls the collector’s market on uncut sheets and gives out official 3x3 squares of them as prizes at tournaments . It’s strict about tracking down unofficially released uncut sheets and misprints and making sure the printer destroys them.
It was shocking, then, when the listings hit eBay, TikTok, and several uncut sheet groups on Facebook at the end of March. Photos and videos showed hundreds of uncut sheets and misprints. There were Minecraft cards and basketball cards, but most of the sheets were Yu-Gi-Oh. There were rare foils (called starlights in Yu-Gi-Oh), misprinted sheets, and rare reprints of old cards.
But the listings were odd. The pictures were often blurry and out of focus, the titles for the listings on eBay didn’t match what was being sold, and they were being sold for far less than they were worth.
“Man I've made over $60,000 off these f****** Yu-Gi-Oh cards out of the trash I'm fixing to go take a video of where I got these hoes from and let you hold it on that now you all pay the premium price when I asked me post off at one at a time."
... continue reading