GoKawiilSign up to see the future, today Can’t-miss innovations from the bleeding edge of science and tech Email address Sign Up Thank you!
Demand for the computing power that undergirds AI models — “compute,” in the lingo of the industry — has skyrocketed.
Tech giants are committing hundreds of billions of dollars to construct massively resource-intensive data centers across the country, but the aging power grid and an increasingly resistant public are quickly turning these expansion efforts into nightmare.
As an alternative, many AI companies — including Elon Musk’s SpaceX — are vowing to move the entire affair into Earth’s orbit, saying their orbital data centers will harvest the Sun’s energy around the clock and convert it into raw computing power.
But the emerging consensus is that the plan isn’t just overly ambitious; it would require several technological revolutions to overcome glaring engineering challenges.
A scathing takedown video — a collaboration between Irish aeronautical engineer Brian McManus from the YouTube channel Real Engineering and tech publication IEEE Spectrum — discusses the many pain points of Starcloud, a Y combinator company that raised $170 million earlier this year to develop data center spacecraft with the help of SpaceX, and how the white paper outlining the project feels far more like it was dreamed up by an AI than a team of human experts.
“It really seems like anyone with some renders and a white paper written by someone being gassed up by an overly agreeable AI can get VC funding these days,” McManus argued. “Billionaires will attempt to pull the rug over your eyes and convince you that this technology makes total sense, but reality is, this technology is dumb.”
The Truth about Space Data Centers
The scathing rebuke comes not long after SpaceX’s IPO, which turned the rocket company into one of the most valuable companies in the world over night. A huge chunk of its multitrillion-dollar valuation is tied up in Musk’s orbital data center vision, setting enormous stakes — and once again illustrating how much Wall Street is leaning on the richest man in the world’s beliefs, despite his abysmal track record when it comes to making good on his promises.
The engineering challenges of building out a constellation of enormous data centers in space are numerous.
... continue reading