Academic paper on Z-Library cites nonexistent TorrentFreak article
A peer-reviewed paper on Z-Library, published this month in New Review of Academic Librarianship by two Nigerian university librarians, cites a 2021 TorrentFreak article titled 'Publishers continue crackdown on shadow libraries' that was never published. TorrentFreak says several other sources in the paper also cannot be located, and the authors have disclosed using AI tools in writing it.
GoKawiil's interpretation of the reporting above, not reported fact.
The incident points to a growing problem of AI-generated citations fabricating sources that sound plausible but don't exist, which can slip past peer review and distort the academic record. It is also notable, TorrentFreak observes, because the paper concerns shadow libraries at the same time rightsholders are suing AI companies for allegedly training models on pirated material from sites like Z-Library.
- A published academic paper cites a TorrentFreak article that does not exist.
- The paper's authors acknowledge using AI tools, which may explain the fabricated references.
- Other cited sources in the paper are also reportedly unverifiable, raising broader concerns about AI-assisted research integrity.
Source: torrentfreak.com, 2026-10-24
Published there as: “AI-Assisted Paper on Z-Library Cites a TorrentFreak Article That Doesn't Exist”
Read the original report → The summary and analysis above are GoKawiil's own, written from reporting by the source above. Facts and quotes belong to the original publisher.