Historian argues AI's blandness makes eccentric scholarly taste more valuable
A history educator reflects on the late Oxford historian Allan Chapman, recalling him as an unusually idiosyncratic mentor steeped in pre-modern ways of thinking. The writer argues that as AI models become capable of memorization-based teaching and brute-force archival research, they converge on a median, clichéd intellectual style that lacks genuine 'research taste' in humanistic fields.
GoKawiil's interpretation of the reporting above, not reported fact.
The author suggests that if AI increasingly handles rote research and standardized teaching, human value in scholarship may shift toward eccentricity, creativity, and the ability to inhabit unfamiliar historical worldviews. This framing implies educators and historians should prioritize cultivating unusual intellectual paths rather than conventional ones, though this remains the author's own speculative judgment about where AI's limitations lie.
- Essay reflects on mentorship from historian Allan Chapman, who died earlier this year.
- Author claims AI models excel at memorization and archival brute-force work but default to a bland, averaged-out perspective.
- Piece argues eccentricity and creativity in scholarship will grow in importance as AI reshapes history education and research.
Source: resobscura.substack.com — Benjamin Breen, 2026-11-10
Published there as: “Research taste in history: the importance of learning Babylonian math”
Read the original report → The summary and analysis above are GoKawiil's own, written from reporting by the source above. Facts and quotes belong to the original publisher.