Nature Portfolio reports results of early-career researcher co-review programme
Nature Portfolio has published its first large-scale analysis of its Early Career Researcher (ECR) Co-Review programme, which lets senior reviewers bring early-career colleagues into the peer-review process while retaining final responsibility. Based on data from 78,661 reviewers and 24,645 manuscripts submitted to Nature and Nature Communications, the analysis found ECRs made up 17% of reviewers at Nature and 11% at Nature Communications. The programme, which began with Nature Reviews journals before expanding, also includes training for participating ECRs and a pathway to independent reviewing.
GoKawiil's interpretation of the reporting above, not reported fact.
The data suggest the scheme is measurably increasing ECR participation in peer review and may be helping narrow gender disparities among reviewers, according to the analysis. Giving early-career researchers formal credit and training could address long-standing complaints that they do reviewing work without recognition while senior colleagues take credit. Wider ECR involvement could also bring reviewers' familiarity with current techniques and technologies into the evaluation of new research.
- ECRs made up 17% of Nature reviewers and 11% of Nature Communications reviewers in the study period
- Analysis drew on data from 78,661 reviewers and 24,645 manuscripts
- Programme pairs ECRs with senior reviewers, offers training, and later invites independent reviewing
Source: nature.com, 2026-11-17
Published there as: “Open up peer review to early-career researchers”
Read the original report → The summary and analysis above are GoKawiil's own, written from reporting by the source above. Facts and quotes belong to the original publisher.