Skip to content
Tech News
← Back to articles

I Sell SEO for a Living — Here’s My Checklist for Hiring an Agency That Actually Gets Results

read original more articles
Why This Matters

This article highlights the importance of carefully evaluating SEO agencies beyond promises of quick rankings, emphasizing strategic questions that reveal true expertise. For consumers and the industry, it underscores the need for transparency and realistic expectations in SEO partnerships to ensure meaningful results. Making informed decisions can prevent costly mistakes and foster genuine growth through effective SEO practices.

Key Takeaways

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Listen to this post

Key Takeaways Hiring the right SEO agency starts with asking better questions, not believing bigger promises.

This article explains how to evaluate an SEO agency’s strategy, audit process, reporting, and business acumen before signing a contract.

When a prospect signs my proposal, I usually know within the first three minutes of the discovery call whether they’ll get good results from any agency they hire — not just mine. The clients who get burned by SEO firms aren’t unlucky. They’re just asking the wrong questions on the way in.

I’ve sat on both sides of those calls for years. I’ve watched founders sign contracts that read like horoscopes and then wonder, six months later, why their dashboard hasn’t moved. I’ve also watched founders walk out of slick, expensive pitches and into stronger relationships with smaller shops that actually moved the needle.

If I were the buyer, here’s exactly how I’d vet an SEO partner — and the questions I’d ask before signing anything.

Ask how they define a win, not what they guarantee

Any agency that guarantees page-one rankings is doing one of three things: bidding on long-tail terms nobody searches, paying for clicks in dark corners of ad networks or lying. Google says plainly in its Search Essentials documentation that no one — including Google itself — can guarantee a specific ranking position. Ask the agency for their definition of success, in writing, before the contract starts.

The right answers sound like: qualified traffic growth, ranked terms with commercial intent, assisted conversions and branded search lift. The wrong answers are position numbers without context.

... continue reading