Metascience gains policy traction as ERC grant success rates plunge to 5%
The European Research Council's main grant scheme now accepts only about 5% of applicants, a drop partly attributed to a surge in AI-assisted submissions. In response, some funders have begun experimenting with lotteries to allocate certain grants, a practice informed by years of metascience research into how science itself is organised and evaluated. A new report, Seize the Meta Moment, from London's Research on Research Institute, documents how several governments have set up dedicated metascience units to shape funding and policy decisions.
GoKawiil's interpretation of the reporting above, not reported fact.
The shift suggests governments are increasingly treating the study of science as a tool for designing funding systems rather than merely observing them, which could reshape how researchers compete for money. Nature's editorial framing implies a caution: if policymakers use metascience data to justify control over funding mechanisms without keeping scientists and evidence central, the field's credibility and usefulness could be undermined. The rise of lotteries as a funding method also signals growing acceptance that traditional peer review may not scale well against surging application volumes, partly driven by AI tools.
- ERC grant success rates have fallen to roughly 5%, partly due to AI-assisted applications increasing submission volumes.
- Some research funders are adopting lottery-based selection as a fairer alternative to traditional competitive review.
- A new report highlights growing government investment in metascience units to inform funding and research policy.
Source: nature.com, 2026-11-10
Published there as: “Metascience should be a source of evidence, not a means of control”
Read the original report → The summary and analysis above are GoKawiil's own, written from reporting by the source above. Facts and quotes belong to the original publisher.