Imperial College researchers debate whether academia should adopt industry's approach to failure
At the Failure in Science Conference held in April, Imperial College London's Dr Nejra van Zalk led a session questioning why academic research is often slower to abandon unsuccessful projects than industry. Scientist Nessa Carey, who has worked across academia, industry and as a freelancer, discussed her experiences of failure in both settings, noting that industry tends to cut losses on failing programmes more quickly than academic institutions do.
GoKawiil's interpretation of the reporting above, not reported fact.
The discussion suggests that funding and institutional incentives may shape which research areas get prioritized, such as obesity drugs over pediatric musculoskeletal treatments, according to van Zalk's framing at the conference. This raises questions about whether academic research culture could become more efficient by adopting risk assessment and project-abandonment practices more common in industry, though the conference did not present this as settled conclusion.
- Imperial College London's Good Science Project examines research culture including attitudes toward failure
- Industry reportedly abandons failing projects faster and quantifies risk differently than academia
- The conference raised questions about how funding priorities are set across different health research areas
Source: nature.com — Byrne, 2026-11-17
Published there as: “Is academia’s risk-averse culture stifling scientific discovery?”
Read the original report → The summary and analysis above are GoKawiil's own, written from reporting by the source above. Facts and quotes belong to the original publisher.