The Verge details its vetting process for Black Friday deal coverage
The Verge says it receives dozens of daily pitches from brands wanting their Black Friday deals publicized, and explains the research it does to verify whether offers are genuine. It cites a Groundwork Collaborative study tracking Amazon prices in 2024 and 2025, which found nearly a third of advertised deals offered no real savings during sales events, and about a tenth were actually pricier than in the preceding month. Amazon told journalist Ronan Farrow its 'List Price' reflects 90-180 days of pricing data from Amazon and competitors, not the 30-day window Groundwork used.
GoKawiil's interpretation of the reporting above, not reported fact.
The discrepancy between Amazon's stated pricing methodology and outside researchers' findings suggests shoppers may struggle to verify whether advertised 'List Price' comparisons are meaningful. Media outlets explaining their vetting criteria could be seen as an attempt to build trust with readers skeptical of inflated discount claims during major shopping events. The underlying data suggests inflated discount marketing is not isolated to one retailer, which may affect how consumers approach deal-hunting broadly.
- Groundwork Collaborative found nearly 1 in 3 Amazon 'deals' showed no real discount during 2024-2025 Black Friday/Cyber Monday events.
- About 10% of tracked deals were pricier during sales events than in the prior month, per the same study.
- Amazon disputes the methodology, saying its List Price draws from 90-180 days of pricing data rather than 30 days.
Source: theverge.com — Cameron Faulkner, 2026-11-18
Published there as: “How The Verge is picking which Black Friday deals to share”
Read the original report → The summary and analysis above are GoKawiil's own, written from reporting by the source above. Facts and quotes belong to the original publisher.