GoKawiilOther Video Doorbells to Consider
I've tested several other video doorbells. These are the ones that narrowly missed out on a place above.
Photograph: Simon Hill
SwitchBot Smart Video Doorbell for $100: I don't love the design of this wide doorbell, but it does come with a wee display that you can use to view who’s there and answer. This could be handy for folks who don’t want to rely on a phone and it lets anyone in the house check who is calling. Video quality is decent, though the frame rate is limited to 15, and the display is low res. You can record locally, and there’s a subscription option if you want cloud storage. Sadly, I found the display was often slow to wake up, and sometimes I had trouble playing back recorded videos.
Aqara G400 Select for $100: This wired doorbell from Aqara is a mixed bag. It’s affordable, comes with a chime, and offers decent video quality (up to 2K). There’s local video storage if you insert a microSD card. It supports PoE or regular doorbell wiring, and has onboard motion and person detection. But it’s a big, chunky lump of plastic, night vision is below par, and you need a HomeGuardian subscription to unlock smarter AI detection (faces, animals, vehicles, and packages), rich notifications with screenshots, and AI video search. The subscription starts from $5 per month ($50 for a year) and also gives you 90-day cloud storage. Alternatively, you can use this doorbell with Apple HomeKit Secure Video (though it will limit the resolution), or with your own NVR or NAS, as it supports RTSP and ONVIF. It also works with other smart home options (Amazon, Google, and Samsung), but it lacks the Matter and Zigbee connectivity of the Aqara G410 above.
Philips Hue Secure Video Doorbell for $170: After a fiddly installation, you get a stylish doorbell offering sharp 2K resolution day or night and a wide view that takes in your whole porch. Notifications are swift and reliable, and you can sync up your Hue lights in interesting ways. But if you don’t already have a Philips Hue setup, I’d pick something from above instead. There’s no local storage option and you must buy a Smart Chime separately. Although you can get 24 hours of video for free, the false alerts will drive you mad. You must subscribe (from $40 a year) to get vital features, like people detection, activity zones, and back-to-back video recording.
Wyze Battery Video Doorbell for $66: Another solid budget option, you get decently sharp 1536 x 1536 resolution video with a 150-degree field of view from this doorbell. You can record locally on a microSD card and there’s good smart home connectivity, but you need a Wyze subscription, from $3 per month, to get person, package, pet, and vehicle detection, back-to-back video recording, and rich alerts (it’s not worth getting without this subscription). The indoor chime is sold separately, and if you want advanced features like facial recognition or descriptive alerts you have to pay more ($10 or $20 a month).
Photograph: Simon Hill
Logitech Circle View Doorbell for $200: As close as you can get to an Apple video doorbell, this compact hardwired doorbell boasts a 160-degree field of view with a 3:4 portrait aspect ratio that takes in your whole porch. Video is crisp and clear, in bright or low light, and the live feed is impressively quick to load. The notification system can tell the difference between animals, people, and vehicles, and will start to recognize familiar faces over time. It works directly through the Apple Home app, though there are pros and cons to Apple's HomeKit Secure Video. Ten days of encrypted videos are stored in your iCloud account (if you have a 50-gigabyte subscription or higher). Alerts come via Apple devices, but your regular chime will also sound when this doorbell is pressed. I love that live video pops up on the Apple Watch or Apple TV when someone rings the doorbell. The complete lack of support for Android or Alexa will turn some people off, and I encountered several issues with this doorbell cutting out and having to be rebooted at the fuse box.
Amazon Blink Doorbell for $60: One of the cheapest doorbells worth considering, (wait for one of Amazon’s frequent discounts to save even more) the Blink Video Doorbell only needs two AA batteries to run for months. But you need a subscription unless you buy with the Sync module (I recommend it). The Blink Basic subscription is $3 a month or $30 a year. Video quality is 1080p with a limited field of view (135 degrees horizontal and only 80 degrees vertical). The lack of HDR shows in mixed light, with bright areas blowing out and shaded areas losing detail. If you have a person at the door with light behind them, it can be tough to see their face. Notifications lacked images or video and were slightly slower than some of the competition, but they always came through. The two-way audio is passable.
... continue reading